Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are increasingly included in chemistry and life-science curricula, yet students often struggle to interpret simulation outputs and to integrate multiple structural descriptors into coherent explanations. These difficulties reflect the epistemic nature of MD as an interpretative practice, where conclusions must be justified by coordinating heterogeneous and sometimes ambiguous indicators rather than by applying algorithmic procedures. This study reports the design and classroom implementation of a Team-Based Learning (TBL) application activity aimed at supporting students’ reasoning during the interpretation of molecular dynamics data in a graduate-level physical chemistry course for life-science students. The activity foregrounded comparison of alternative molecular scenarios, integration of multiple MD descriptors (e.g., RMSD, RMSF, interaction persistence), and collective justification of decisions. Students worked with simplified but biologically plausible datasets to engage in sense-making under conditions of uncertainty. A deliberately constrained form of AI-supported tutoring was integrated as a Socratic scaffold during the application phase. The AI tutor prompted reflection and justification while explicitly avoiding the provision of answers, thereby supporting reasoning without displacing students’ epistemic agency or the central role of peer discussion. The study addressed three research questions concerning how student teams integrated multiple MD descriptors, the quality of team justifications, and students’ perceptions of the AI-supported scaffold. Analysis of team artefacts using an analytic rubric indicated that most teams coordinated multiple metrics and articulated coherent interpretations based on converging evidence, although reasoning remained partially descriptive in some cases. Student feedback highlighted the central role of the TBL structure in supporting engagement and sense-making, while the AI tutor was used sparingly but perceived as appropriate and useful. Overall, the findings suggest that Team-Based Learning provides a productive framework for teaching molecular dynamics as an interpretative practice and that pedagogically constrained AI can complement collaborative reasoning without undermining students’ responsibility for interpretation.

Lombardo, R. (2026). Team-Based Learning and AI-Supported Socratic Scaffolding for Interpreting Molecular Dynamics Data. In IECCE ECRICE 2026 - Book of Abstracts (pp. 67-68). Turkish Chemical Society.

Team-Based Learning and AI-Supported Socratic Scaffolding for Interpreting Molecular Dynamics Data

Lombardo, Renato
2026-01-01

Abstract

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are increasingly included in chemistry and life-science curricula, yet students often struggle to interpret simulation outputs and to integrate multiple structural descriptors into coherent explanations. These difficulties reflect the epistemic nature of MD as an interpretative practice, where conclusions must be justified by coordinating heterogeneous and sometimes ambiguous indicators rather than by applying algorithmic procedures. This study reports the design and classroom implementation of a Team-Based Learning (TBL) application activity aimed at supporting students’ reasoning during the interpretation of molecular dynamics data in a graduate-level physical chemistry course for life-science students. The activity foregrounded comparison of alternative molecular scenarios, integration of multiple MD descriptors (e.g., RMSD, RMSF, interaction persistence), and collective justification of decisions. Students worked with simplified but biologically plausible datasets to engage in sense-making under conditions of uncertainty. A deliberately constrained form of AI-supported tutoring was integrated as a Socratic scaffold during the application phase. The AI tutor prompted reflection and justification while explicitly avoiding the provision of answers, thereby supporting reasoning without displacing students’ epistemic agency or the central role of peer discussion. The study addressed three research questions concerning how student teams integrated multiple MD descriptors, the quality of team justifications, and students’ perceptions of the AI-supported scaffold. Analysis of team artefacts using an analytic rubric indicated that most teams coordinated multiple metrics and articulated coherent interpretations based on converging evidence, although reasoning remained partially descriptive in some cases. Student feedback highlighted the central role of the TBL structure in supporting engagement and sense-making, while the AI tutor was used sparingly but perceived as appropriate and useful. Overall, the findings suggest that Team-Based Learning provides a productive framework for teaching molecular dynamics as an interpretative practice and that pedagogically constrained AI can complement collaborative reasoning without undermining students’ responsibility for interpretation.
2026
Team-Based Learning, Molecular Dynamics, Chemistry Education Research, Disciplinary Reasoning, AI-Supported Scaffolding, Collaborative Learning
9786259418988
Lombardo, R. (2026). Team-Based Learning and AI-Supported Socratic Scaffolding for Interpreting Molecular Dynamics Data. In IECCE ECRICE 2026 - Book of Abstracts (pp. 67-68). Turkish Chemical Society.
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
OP082.pdf

Solo gestori archvio

Tipologia: Versione Editoriale
Dimensione 533.91 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
533.91 kB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri   Richiedi una copia

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/10447/721503
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact