Hesiod claims to have received from the Muses the gift to sing the future and the past, but looking at Hesiodic texts handed down by tradition the prediction of the future is missing. So either Hesiod lied, or he hid the Muses’ gift that would be most useful to mortals, or he kept his prophecies secret with the intention of disclosing them on a future occasion. The confidence placed in the content of his epic poems constitutes in itself a thorny problem: thus, the poetic tradition itself is fraught with substantially unsolvable difficulties. This paper discusses the importance of Lucian’s Dialogue with Hesiod, where the examination of the poetic tradition is achieved through literary evaluation. At the same time, the contribution highlights the praise of poetic licence, which is the freedom of the pseudos. However, Hesiod’s poetry seems to become the object of a demystification, given that Lycinus unmasks its presumed authority, by distorting its meanings and attacking the naivety of readers or listeners.

Tonin, A. (2026). L’Esiodo di Luciano, tra smontaggio della tradizione e libertà della poesia. In L. Beltramini, A. Camerotto, V. Melis, G. Palermo (a cura di), PARODIA IN AZIONE. Paradigmi, strategie ed effetti in Luciano di Samosata (pp. 179-194). Palermo : Palermo University Press.

L’Esiodo di Luciano, tra smontaggio della tradizione e libertà della poesia

ALESSANDRO TONIN
2026-11-01

Abstract

Hesiod claims to have received from the Muses the gift to sing the future and the past, but looking at Hesiodic texts handed down by tradition the prediction of the future is missing. So either Hesiod lied, or he hid the Muses’ gift that would be most useful to mortals, or he kept his prophecies secret with the intention of disclosing them on a future occasion. The confidence placed in the content of his epic poems constitutes in itself a thorny problem: thus, the poetic tradition itself is fraught with substantially unsolvable difficulties. This paper discusses the importance of Lucian’s Dialogue with Hesiod, where the examination of the poetic tradition is achieved through literary evaluation. At the same time, the contribution highlights the praise of poetic licence, which is the freedom of the pseudos. However, Hesiod’s poetry seems to become the object of a demystification, given that Lycinus unmasks its presumed authority, by distorting its meanings and attacking the naivety of readers or listeners.
nov-2026
Settore HELL-01/B - Lingua e letteratura greca
Tonin, A. (2026). L’Esiodo di Luciano, tra smontaggio della tradizione e libertà della poesia. In L. Beltramini, A. Camerotto, V. Melis, G. Palermo (a cura di), PARODIA IN AZIONE. Paradigmi, strategie ed effetti in Luciano di Samosata (pp. 179-194). Palermo : Palermo University Press.
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
08TONINPARODIAINAZIONE2026PUP.pdf

accesso aperto

Descrizione: contributo integrale scaricabile online previa registrazione al link https://unipapress.com/book/parodia-in-azione-paradigmi-strategie-ed-effetti-in-luciano-di-samosata/
Tipologia: Versione Editoriale
Dimensione 554.89 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
554.89 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/10447/721649
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact