Elevated carbon dioxide does not increase macroalgal community photosynthesis

Ocean acidification, driven by rising atmospheric carbon dioxide levels, has impacts on marine ecosystems. While elevated carbon dioxide concentrations have the potential to enhance Blue Carbon fixation and storage, the response of community photosynthesis in macroalgal-dominated ecosystems remains poorly understood. Here, we investigated the effects of elevated carbon dioxide on macroalgal communities using volcanic carbon dioxide vents as a natural analogue of ocean acidification. Net community photosynthesis was assessed using chambers positioned on the seafloor as well as water mass dynamics monitoring. Despite a shift in algal community composition, only minimal differences in net community photosynthesis were observed between reference and high carbon dioxide sites. The high carbon dioxide site had a lower abundance of algal species with carbon dioxide concentrating mechanisms, based on δ13C isotope measurements. Carbon dioxide concentrating mechanisms facilitate photosynthesis under present-day levels of carbon dioxide in seawater, resulting in a negligible effect of elevated carbon dioxide on macroalgal community photosynthesis. These results challenge the assumption that ocean acidification will enhance Blue Carbon uptake and storage, necessitating a reevaluation of this perspective.