Archivio istituzionale della ricerca dell'Università degli Studi di Palermo
IRIS è il sistema di gestione integrata dei dati della ricerca (persone, pubblicazioni, progetti, attività) adottato dall’Università di Palermo, e ha lo scopo di raccogliere, conservare, documentare, e diffondere ad accesso aperto le informazioni relative alla produzione scientifica degli autori afferenti all’Ateneo.
EnglishThe choice and/or the balancing between effectivess and legality in the creation of States is, today, one of the most hotly debated issues in the international legal scholarship. Should a state-like entity formed in breach of the peremptory norm prohibiting the use of force or of the principle of self-determination (not) be considered as a State for the purposes of international law? The answer differs according to what theoretical premises are adopted. For those who believe that the State is a social person, and its creation basically a historical occurrence, the law cannot cancel its very existence. On the other hand, if State-creation is also a matter of law, one might agree that “[a]n apparently successful secession still has to pass the international law test”. The present writer expresses a somehow intermediate position,based on the view that a State is a real, not a legal person, but at the same time, taking note of the fact that the international community requires respect for some norms during the process of State-creation. Their violation, however, does not automatically transform the “illegitimately born” entity into a legally non-existent non-State. At most, it creates a situation of social isolation which gives rise to a factual limitation of its legal sphere.
TANCREDI, A. (2006). A normative ‘due process’ in the creation of States through secession. In KOHEN, & M. G. (a cura di), Secession International Law Perspective (pp. 171-207). CAMBRIDGE : Cambridge University Press [10.1017/CBO9780511494215.008].
| Data di pubblicazione: | 2006 | |
| Titolo: | A normative ‘due process’ in the creation of States through secession | |
| Autori: | ||
| Citazione: | TANCREDI, A. (2006). A normative ‘due process’ in the creation of States through secession. In KOHEN, & M. G. (a cura di), Secession International Law Perspective (pp. 171-207). CAMBRIDGE : Cambridge University Press [10.1017/CBO9780511494215.008]. | |
| Abstract: | The choice and/or the balancing between effectivess and legality in the creation of States is, today, one of the most hotly debated issues in the international legal scholarship. Should a state-like entity formed in breach of the peremptory norm prohibiting the use of force or of the principle of self-determination (not) be considered as a State for the purposes of international law? The answer differs according to what theoretical premises are adopted. For those who believe that the State is a social person, and its creation basically a historical occurrence, the law cannot cancel its very existence. On the other hand, if State-creation is also a matter of law, one might agree that “[a]n apparently successful secession still has to pass the international law test”. The present writer expresses a somehow intermediate position,based on the view that a State is a real, not a legal person, but at the same time, taking note of the fact that the international community requires respect for some norms during the process of State-creation. Their violation, however, does not automatically transform the “illegitimately born” entity into a legally non-existent non-State. At most, it creates a situation of social isolation which gives rise to a factual limitation of its legal sphere. | |
| Digital Object Identifier (DOI): | http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511494215.008 | |
| Appare nelle tipologie: | 2.01 Capitolo o Saggio |
File in questo prodotto:
Copyright © 2022